Who pays return shipping? The law, what customers expect, and the maths
Published on October 25, 2026

“I got the refund, but €4.95 is missing. Is that a mistake?” You get this email when you deduct return shipping and the customer learns about it for the first time by looking at their bank statement. It is not the consequence of your decision to pass on the cost. It is the consequence of that decision not being where the customer was looking.
Who pays for return shipping is one of the few return questions where you actually have room to decide. The law allows both. Customers have a clear expectation. And the maths depends on your product range. This article goes through the three levels, shows how other merchants handle it, and ends with the wording that explains the deduction before that email arrives.
What the law says
Under Section 357 (5) German Civil Code (BGB), the consumer bears the direct cost of returning the goods if you informed them about it beforehand. Beforehand means: in the withdrawal information, before the contract is concluded. If that notice is missing, you bear the cost, even if you intended to pass it on.
Two things that are often confused:
- Outbound shipping is a different matter. Under Section 357 (2) BGB, you have to refund the shipping costs of the original delivery on withdrawal, at least at the level of the cheapest standard shipping. Only the return leg can be charged to the customer.
- This is about withdrawal, not defects. If the goods are faulty or you sent the wrong item, it is a warranty case. Then you bear the cost of the return leg, regardless of your returns policy.
If you opt for paid returns, keep one more thing in mind: if a customer sends the goods back without your label using their own postage, they may have paid more than your contract rate. A provided label with a fixed deduction is simpler for both sides. The general framework of withdrawal is in Right of withdrawal vs. goodwill. This is not legal advice.
What customers expect
The expectation is clear. According to a Bitkom survey from June 2025, free returns are important to 94 % of online shoppers. From the same survey: 49 % have at some point kept a product because returning it was too complicated. Cost is a form of complication.
This expectation has grown over years. The Research Group Returns Management at the University of Bamberg found in its 2022 European merchant survey that 88.7 % of surveyed merchants in Germany offered free returns, compared to 52.4 % in the rest of Europe. German customers have therefore been used to returns costing nothing for years. If you deviate from that, you are working against a habit, not just a preference.
What this means for you: paid returns are possible, but they are a disadvantage in comparison that the customer sees immediately, provided you disclose it honestly. And you should disclose it honestly, see above.
How other merchants handle it
The EHI study 2025 on shipping and returns management, which surveyed 124 online merchants from the DACH region, shows three camps: 49.2 % of merchants cover return shipping in full, 32.8 % use a mixed model depending on order value or return reason, and 18 % have customers pay.
The mixed model is the interesting group. Typical variants:
- Free above a minimum order value. Below €40 or €50 the customer pays, above that the merchant does. This protects the margin on small baskets, where a return eats up the whole transaction.
- Free for exchanges, paid for refunds. Whoever wants the other size pays nothing. Whoever wants the money pays for the return leg. This steers towards exchanges; more on that in Exchange instead of refund.
- Free the first time, paid from the third return in a short period. This targets serial returners and leaves normal customers alone. But it is technically more demanding and has to be communicated clearly.
- Free for defects or wrong deliveries, paid for change of mind. That is the legal position anyway, but rarely stated this clearly.
The maths for your shop
Whether paid returns pay off depends on three numbers: your return rate, your average basket and your margin. A worked example, everything as an assumption:
Say you have 1,000 orders a month, an average basket of €60 and a return rate of 20 %. That is 200 returns. Assume return postage of €5, plus handling. According to EHI 2025, 53.3 % of surveyed merchants calculate handling costs of up to €10 per returned item. Let us take €7. Then each return costs you €12, or €2,400 a month.
Now you introduce a €4.95 return fee. Two effects:
- Direct: you get €4.95 back on every return. At an unchanged rate, that is €990 a month.
- Indirect: some customers stop ordering from you because a competitor offers free returns. And some customers order fewer items to choose from, which lowers the rate. How big either effect is, nobody knows in advance. You can only measure it.
The honest answer: with a €60 basket and a 20 % rate, a return largely eats the order's margin, and a fee is worth a test. With a €200 basket and an 8 % rate, the fee is a reputation risk for little money. There is no general answer, only your calculation.
What happens when you introduce the fee
A test is not a switch you flip and forget. What to watch:
- Conversion on the product page as soon as the notice appears there. This is the most expensive effect, and it shows first.
- Return rate, split by reason. If the share of “ordered several variants” drops, the fee is working where it should. According to Bitkom 2024, 29 % of online shoppers who have ever returned something say they deliberately ordered several variants. That is the group a fee reaches.
- Support requests about the deduction. If they come, the problem is not the fee but the communication.
- Reviews that mention the fee. One or two are normal, a cluster is not.
Set a period of two to three months and decide then. Whoever withdraws the fee after four weeks because two customers complained has learned nothing.
How to communicate the deduction
The email from the introduction happens because the deduction should have appeared in three places and appeared in none. The three places:
- Before the purchase. In the withdrawal information (mandatory) and on the shipping costs page (sensible). One sentence is enough: “Returns cost €4.95, which we deduct from the refund. For exchanges or defects, return shipping is free.”
- At the return request. In the returns portal, before the customer generates the label: “Your refund will be €54.05 (€59.00 minus €4.95 return shipping).”
- In the refund email. Amount, deduction, reason. “We have refunded €54.05 to your credit card. €4.95 was deducted for the return label, as shown when you requested the return.”
This is how it works at Humane: if the return fee is stored as a rule, the agent knows it in every reply. If a customer asks before returning what it costs, they get the rule including the exceptions for exchanges and defects. If they ask after the refund why an amount is missing, they get the breakdown from the order in Shopify. Refunds themselves run with approval; whoever has that permission in the helper portal approves them.
Where return shipping sits in the overall process and which emails prevent requests at which point is in the pillar article Returns process for online shops: step by step.
In short
You may pass on return shipping costs if you say so before the purchase; outbound shipping and defect cases stay with you. Customers expect free returns, and just under half of merchants offer them, another third with conditions. Whether a fee pays off for you follows from basket, rate and margin, not from a rule of thumb. If you test it, measure conversion and return reasons over at least two months. And name the deduction in all three places, so the question “Where is my €4.95?” never comes up.
If you want to see how your return fee is explained correctly in every return reply, automatically: try 100 customer requests for free, no credit card required.
Sources
- Section 357 German Civil Code (BGB), consequences of withdrawal
- TextilWirtschaft, New EHI study on return rates (November 2025)
- EHI Retail Institute, Between returns and profitability (November 2025)
- Bitkom, Returns too complicated (June 2025)
- University of Bamberg, Germany is Europe's returns champion (September 2022)
- Bitkom, Online shopping: one in ten purchases is returned (April 2024)