Right of withdrawal vs. goodwill: what you must do and what you can do
Published on October 13, 2026

A customer writes on day 16 after delivery: “I'd like to return the trousers, unfortunately they don't fit.” Two days after the withdrawal period ended. What happens next depends on whether you have asked yourself this question before. If not, you look it up, think about it, maybe ask a colleague, and the customer waits two days for an answer that turns out one way or another. If you have, the answer is in your rules and the email is handled in a minute.
That is exactly the difference between the right of withdrawal and goodwill. The right of withdrawal is the floor the law sets, and it applies whether you like it or not. Goodwill is everything you voluntarily add on top, and you should decide it once instead of afresh in every ticket. This article first explains the obligation, then the optional part, and finally how to write both down so they can be applied in support.
One thing first, because it matters: this article explains the basics of German law in general terms and does not replace legal advice. For your specific withdrawal information and terms, you need someone who knows your shop.
What you must do: the right of withdrawal in outline
Who has it and where it comes from
Under Section 312g German Civil Code (BGB), consumers have a right of withdrawal on distance contracts, meaning purchases through your online shop. This applies to private individuals, not to business customers ordering for their company. The details are in Section 355 BGB: the consumer can withdraw from the contract within 14 days without having to give a reason.
When the period starts
For deliveries of goods, under Section 356 (2) BGB the period does not start with the order but with receipt of the goods. If an order is delivered in several partial shipments, the period runs from receipt of the last one. That matters in support: a customer whose second parcel arrived a week later has a week longer for the whole order.
And one more point that can get expensive: the period only starts once you have properly informed the customer about their right of withdrawal. If that information is missing or faulty, under Section 356 (3) BGB the right of withdrawal only expires twelve months and 14 days after the period would normally have started. A broken withdrawal notice therefore extends the period to more than a year.
How withdrawal is declared
The withdrawal has to be unambiguous, but it needs no particular form and no reason. “I'm sending the trousers back” by email is enough if the intention to withdraw is clear. Sending the declaration in time is enough to meet the deadline; it does not have to reach you within the period. For support, that means: a customer who emails at 11 pm on day 14 has withdrawn in time, even if you only read it on day 15. And: simply sending the goods back without a declaration is strictly speaking not a withdrawal, though in practice most merchants treat it as one.
What happens after withdrawal
The consequences are in Section 357 BGB:
- Return within 14 days (subsection 1). For you, the period runs from receipt of the withdrawal declaration; for the customer, from sending it. The customer has to send the goods back within that time, and you have to refund within that time.
- Refund including standard shipping costs (subsection 2). The outbound shipping is part of the refund. Only the extra cost of a more expensive shipping method chosen by the customer (express) can you keep.
- Same payment method (subsection 3). You refund the way the customer paid. A voucher instead of money only with the customer's express consent.
- Right to withhold (subsection 4). You may withhold the refund until you have the goods back or the customer has provided proof of shipping.
- Return shipping costs (subsection 5). The customer bears the direct cost of returning the goods if you informed them about it beforehand. If you did not, you bear them. What that means in practice is in Who pays return shipping.
Compensation for loss in value: trying on yes, wearing no
The customer may examine the goods the way they could in a store: unpack, look, try on. If the handling goes beyond that and the goods lose value as a result, under Section 357a BGB you can claim compensation, but only if you properly informed the customer about the right of withdrawal. A worn dress with stains is such a case. A tried-on dress without its tag usually is not. The line is hard to draw in individual cases, and that is exactly why compensation should not be decided by a support agent but by a person with the parcel in hand.
Exceptions: where there is no right of withdrawal
Section 312g (2) BGB lists cases where the right of withdrawal does not apply. For shops, the most relevant are:
- goods made to the customer's specifications or clearly personalised (engraving, made to measure)
- goods that spoil quickly
- sealed goods that are not suitable for return for health or hygiene reasons, once the seal has been removed
- sealed audio or video recordings and software, once the seal has been removed
You have to point out these exceptions before the purchase. And importantly: the exception is narrow. “Hygiene products” does not mean all underwear, but sealed goods where the seal was removed.
What you can do: goodwill as a decision, not a feeling
Everything beyond the legal floor is goodwill. And goodwill is a tool, not a sign of weakness. The only question is whether you plan it or whether it happens to you.
The typical goodwill decisions
- A longer period. 30 days instead of 14, 100 days, or until the end of January for Christmas gifts. Customers expect it: according to a Bitkom survey from June 2025, 68 % of online shoppers consider a return period longer than the legal one important. If you grant it, name it in your terms and then apply it consistently.
- Free return shipping. You may charge the customer, most merchants do not. According to the same Bitkom survey, free returns are important to 94 % of respondents.
- Returns outside the right of withdrawal. Personalised goods, opened cosmetics, day 16 instead of day 14. No obligation here, but often a good reason: keeping the customer.
- Waiving compensation. The tag is off, the goods are fine. Argue or refund?
- Refund before receipt. For loyal customers or small amounts, it can be worth not waiting for the parcel.
Goodwill needs rules
The problem with case-by-case goodwill: it is not consistent. One team member refunds on day 16, another does not. The customer who was turned down finds the other one's review and writes a worse one. That is why every goodwill decision belongs in a rule with a condition:
- “Returns until day 30 always, until day 45 for order values under €50, after that only with approval.”
- “Compensation for a missing tag: waive it if the goods are undamaged.”
- “Personalised goods: no withdrawal, but a one-time exchange for a typo in the engraving if we should have caught it.”
This is how it works at Humane: these rules live in the business rules engine and are checked against the order data from Shopify on every return request. The agent sees the delivery date, calculates the period and replies accordingly. On day 16 with a 30-day rule, the reply goes out automatically. On day 50, it lands as a draft with you, because the “only with approval” rule applies. And if you change a draft because you want to be lenient in one case after all, you can turn that into a new rule.
The limit: what does not belong in a rule
A few cases you should deliberately not automate, even if you could:
- Compensation for loss in value. Whether goods were used “beyond examination” is decided by someone with the parcel in hand, not by a text.
- Suspected abuse. Someone returning a worn jacket for the fifth time gets a person, not a standard reply. How to spot patterns is in Detecting return fraud.
- Legal threats. As soon as a customer mentions a lawyer or a consumer protection agency, it is a case for you.
What this looks like in a reply
An example for day 16 with 30-day goodwill, in the tone of a small fashion shop:
Hi Ms Weber, no problem, you can send the trousers back. With us you have 30 days, your order arrived on 2 October, so that works. The return label is attached to this email. As soon as the parcel reaches us, we refund the amount to your original payment method, which takes a few business days depending on your bank. Best, Lena
And for day 50 with no matching rule: no template, but a draft in which you decide. The difference between the two cases is not the tone but who makes the decision.
The full process from request to refund is in the pillar article Returns process for online shops: step by step.
In short
The right of withdrawal sets your floor: 14 days from receipt, no particular form, no reason required, refund within 14 days by the same payment method. Exceptions exist only for the cases named in Section 312g (2) BGB, and compensation only for use beyond examination. Everything above that is goodwill, and goodwill should be a rule, not a mood. Write your goodwill rules down with conditions, let them be applied automatically where they are clear-cut, and keep the cases where someone needs to see the parcel for yourself.
This is not legal advice. Have your withdrawal information and terms checked by someone who knows your shop.
If you want to see how the period and the goodwill rule are checked automatically in every return reply: try 100 customer requests for free, no credit card required.
Sources
- Section 312g German Civil Code (BGB), right of withdrawal
- Section 355 German Civil Code (BGB), right of withdrawal in consumer contracts
- Section 356 German Civil Code (BGB), right of withdrawal in distance contracts
- Section 357 German Civil Code (BGB), consequences of withdrawal
- Section 357a German Civil Code (BGB), compensation for loss in value
- Bitkom, Returns too complicated (June 2025)