Back to blog

Return reasons 2026: why customers really send things back

Published on November 6, 2026

A Humane figurine in a beanie examines a shoe from a box to be sent back at home.

In most returns portals there is a dropdown with six reasons. “Doesn’t fit” gets clicked most often, “Other” second most often, and after that nobody looks at it again. Yet the return reason is the only place where a customer voluntarily tells you what was missing from your product page.

This article collects the figures on return reasons that can be documented for Germany: what customers say in surveys, how the reasons are shifting, what role bracketing and fraud actually play, and what retailers do about it. For each figure, one sentence on what it means for you.

A note on reading them: most of the numbers come from consumer surveys with multiple answers allowed (“Have you ever returned something for this reason?”). They therefore do not add up to 100 percent and say nothing about the share of a reason among all returns in one store. If you want shares per store, you have to count them yourself.

Return reasons at a glance

The most recent representative survey for Germany comes from Bitkom. According to Bitkom (2024), a survey of 1,050 online shoppers, customers have returned items for these reasons:

  • 67 percent: the size did not fit, for example with clothing or furniture.
  • 56 percent: the product was faulty or damaged.
  • 50 percent: they simply did not like the product.
  • 41 percent: the product did not match the picture or description.
  • 37 percent: the product seemed poorly made.
  • 29 percent: the wrong item was delivered.
  • 29 percent: they deliberately ordered more than they needed.
  • 14 percent: they ordered the wrong item by mistake.
  • 13 percent: the delivery arrived later than needed.
  • 9 percent each: they no longer needed the product, or found a better offer.

According to the same survey, German online shoppers send back 11 percent of their online purchases on average.

What this means for you: sort the list by who caused the reason. Size, picture and description are information gaps on your side. Damage and wrong item are process errors in the warehouse and shipping. “Didn’t like it” and “better offer” are customer decisions you can only influence to a limited degree. The first two groups are the bigger ones, and they are yours.

A second survey, the same ranking

A second survey confirms the picture with different numbers. According to KPMG and EHI (2025), an online survey of 500 consumers, the most common return reasons are:

  • Quality defects: 73.8 percent
  • Wrong size: 72.6 percent
  • Damage to the product: 71.2 percent
  • Inaccurate description or deviations from product pictures: 60.4 percent
  • Deliberate double ordering, for example in different sizes or colours: 46.2 percent

The values are higher than Bitkom’s because the question was asked differently, but the top group is the same: size, quality, damage, deviation from the picture.

What this means for you: when two surveys with different methods put the same four reasons at the top, that is not a coincidence. Whatever you do against returns should start with those four. Measures are covered in reducing your return rate: 9 measures.

What shifted within one year

Bitkom asked the same questions a year earlier. According to Bitkom (2023), a survey of 1,024 online shoppers, 54 percent then named “didn’t like it”, 53 percent “faulty or damaged”, 42 percent “didn’t match the picture or description” and 38 percent “poorly made”. 37 percent had deliberately ordered more than they needed, and 10 percent had returned something because of a better offer.

Compared with 2024, one thing stands out: the share of people who deliberately over-order fell from 37 to 29 percent. “Didn’t like it” dropped from 54 to 50 percent, while damage rose from 53 to 56 percent.

What this means for you: two data points are not a trend yet. But the direction matches what retailers observe: customers are ordering a little more deliberately, and the share of genuine defects among returns is growing rather than shrinking. A damaged item is the most expensive return reason, because on top of the return it triggers a support ticket, often a photo, and usually a replacement shipment.

Bracketing: the fitting room in the living room

Bracketing, ordering several sizes or colours and sending the rest back, is the reason retailers complain about most. The figures:

  • According to Bitkom (2024), 29 percent of online shoppers have deliberately ordered more than they needed, down from 37 percent the year before.
  • According to KPMG and EHI (2025), 46.2 percent name deliberate double ordering as a return reason.
  • According to the University of Bamberg (2025), a little over 80 percent of returned parcels and around 90 percent of returned items fall into the fashion segment, the industry where bracketing is common.

What this means for you: from the customer’s point of view, bracketing is not abuse but the fitting room your store does not have. It does not disappear through warnings, but through better size guidance. The University of Bamberg (2019) estimates that measures against size-related returns could save up to 25 percent of returns in the overall market, around 120 million items. A return fee of 2.95 euros per shipment could, by the same estimate, avoid around 16 percent of all returns.

Return fraud and wardrobing: smaller than you think

“Wardrobing” means buying a garment for an occasion, wearing it, and sending it back. The documented figures:

  • TextilWirtschaft (2025) cites a YouGov survey in which 18 percent of people in Germany say they have done this once or several times, men more often than women. Among 15- to 34-year-olds it is 30 percent.
  • In the US, retailers estimate according to NRF and Happy Returns (2025) that 9 percent of all returns are fraudulent. 45 percent of US consumers consider it acceptable to “bend the truth” when making returns.
  • On the retailer side the picture looks different: according to the University of Bamberg (2022), 93.2 percent of returned items are resold as new, and only 1.3 percent are disposed of directly by German retailers.

What this means for you: fraud exists, but it is not the reason for your return rate. If you design your returns rules around the 9 percent of fraudsters, you annoy the 91 percent who return honestly. How to spot the few patterns without suspecting everyone is covered in detecting return fraud.

How the returns policy shapes the return

The return reason decides whether a customer sends something back. The returns policy decides whether they order at all and whether they come back.

  • According to Bitkom (2025), free return shipping matters to 94 percent of German online shoppers, and a fast refund to just as many. 68 percent consider a return period longer than the legal one essential. And 49 percent have kept a product at least once because the returns process was too complicated.
  • According to KPMG and EHI (2025), 36.6 percent of customers did not buy from the same retailer again after a negative returns experience.
  • According to Sendcloud (2024), 30 percent of German consumers do not order at all if the return window is shorter than 30 days. 44 percent of Sendcloud’s retailer customers charge a return fee, 5.66 euros on average.
  • In the US, according to Narvar (2025), 90 percent of customers check the returns policy before buying, and 76 percent will not buy again after a poor returns experience.

What this means for you: the number to remember is 36.6 percent. More than one in three customers who have a bad returns experience does not come back. The return itself costs you postage once. The lost customer costs you every future order. What the law requires and what you offer beyond it is covered in right of withdrawal vs. goodwill.

What retailers do about it, and what works

  • According to EHI (2023), 86 percent of retailers see detailed product information as the decisive measure against returns, 42 percent contact options for personal advice, 40 percent address verification.
  • According to EHI (2024), 81 percent of retailers record return reasons systematically, and 67 percent derive measures from them.
  • According to EHI (2025), however, only 29.5 percent capture the reasons fully automatically, and 34.4 percent still do it manually. 53.3 percent of retailers put the cost per returned item at up to 10 euros, and 27 percent cannot quantify their costs.
  • TextilWirtschaft (2025) reports from the same EHI study what retailers rely on: detailed product information (75.2 percent), high-quality product pictures and videos (62.8 percent), quality assurance before shipping (47.9 percent). Almost 44 percent specifically check conspicuous returns.

The measures match the reasons: product information against “doesn’t fit” and “not as described”, quality assurance against “damaged” and “wrong item”. What is missing is the link between the two. Four in five retailers record reasons, but only two in three do something with them, and a third still type the reasons in by hand.

What this means for your support

The return reason also decides what support should do. “Doesn’t fit” is a case for an exchange instead of a refund, with a sizing note in the reply. “Damaged” is a case for a photo, a fast replacement and a note to the warehouse. “Didn’t like it” is a case for a smooth return with no follow-up questions. If you answer all three with the same standard email, you give away revenue on the first, loyalty on the second and time on the third.

This is how it works at Humane: the customer states the reason in the returns portal (a paid add-on), and the rules for deadlines, goodwill and refunds are stored. The agent answers follow-ups (“Has my return arrived?”, “When will I be refunded?”) with the actual status from Shopify, and refunds only go out after approval. For damaged goods it asks for the photo instead of refunding blindly. What it cannot do is write your size chart for you. But the return reasons tell you which size chart to write first. How to offer exchanges systematically is covered in exchange instead of refund.

In short

  • Two surveys (Bitkom 2024, KPMG/EHI 2025) put the same reasons at the top: wrong size, damage or defect, deviation from picture and description.
  • The two biggest groups, information gaps and process errors, sit with the retailer, not the customer.
  • The share of deliberate bracketing fell from 37 to 29 percent within a year according to Bitkom; size guidance could avoid up to a quarter of all returns according to the University of Bamberg.
  • Fraud is real but small: 9 percent of returns in the US, and 93 percent of returns in Germany are resold as new.
  • 36.6 percent of customers do not buy again after a bad returns experience. The returns process is customer retention, not logistics.
  • Recording reasons is not enough. Only those who evaluate them automatically and reply differently per reason get something out of it.

The whole process from request to refund is covered in the returns process step by step. Which rates are typical in your industry is covered in return rates in Germany by industry.

If you want to see what return requests look like when they are answered with the real reason and the real status: try 100 customer requests for free, no credit card required.

Sources